John Locke

1690

British philosopher who rejected Descartes’ notion of innate ideas and insisted that the mind is at birth a “blank slate”, published An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, which emphasized empiricism over speculation. His views endorsed the nurture (environmental) side of the nature-nurture controversy.

Type of Controversy

Nature Nurture

  • powered by Academic Web Services | Grand Canyon University ©

The Interpretation of Dreams

1900

Sigmund Freud published this book, A major theoretical work on psychoanalysis. Freud’s theory emphasized unconscious determinants of behavior, and favored the discontinuity side of the continuity-discontinuity controversy. Moreover, it stressed determinism over free choice.

Type of Controversy

Free Will vs. Determinism,

Continuity vs. Discontinuity,

Early vs. Later Development

John Watson

1913

Outlined the behaviorist manifesto in a Psychological Review article, “Psychology as the Behaviorist views it. In 1920, he and Rosalie Raynor reported conditioning a fear reaction in a child called “Little Albert.” The behaviorists emphasized the nurture side of the nature-nurture controversy, and also emphasized the continuity side of the continuity-discontinuity controversy. Moreover, it endorsed determinism over free choice.

Type of Controversy

Continuity vs. Discontinuity

Free Will vs. Determinism.

Related years

1923

Jean Piaget

1923

Jean Piaget, the famous developmental psychologist, published The Language and Thought of the Child. His theory emphasized conscious processes over unconscious ones, and his stage theory emphasized discontinuity of development over continuity.

Type of Controversy

Continuity vs. Discontinuity

Related years

1913

Noam Chomsky

1959

Linguist Noam Chomsky publishes a critique of B.F. Skinner’s Verbal Behavior.  Chomsky believed that language was infinitely generative in that with a finite number of words and rules, one could create infinite novel sentences.  Chomsky also proposed the idea that humans had an innate “Language Acquisition Device,” which allows humans to be biologically predisposed to learn language.  He argued that unlike the behaviorist view of language acquisition, humans did not need to be reinforced for speech in order to acquire language.

Type of Controversy

Innate capacity for Language Acquisition (Supports Nature)

Thomas Szasz

1961

Thomas Szasz criticizes psyichiatrists and medical doctors and argues that mental illness is simply a euphamism for behaviors disapproved of by society.

Stanley Milgram

1963

Stanley Milgram publishes his classic study of obedience.  Influenced by the events that occurred during WWII, Milgram conducted a study to test the limits of human obedience.  Under the guise of conducting a study of punishment on learning, Milgram ordered participants to administer increasingly powerful electric shocks to a “learner,” (who was actually a confederate and was not receiving any shocks).

 

When participants protested, they were encouraged to go on, and in the classic studies, over 2/3 of participants, regardless of age, gender, or occupation, went so far as to administer what they believed to be a lethal shock to the “learner.”  Milgram’s study was controversial and served as a catalyst for stricter ethical guidelines in research.

 

Phillip Zimbardo

1971

In 1971, social psychologist Phillip Zimbardo conducted his infamous Stanford Prison Experiment, in which college men were assigned to be prisoners or guards in a simulated prison situation.  The study was designed to examine the effect of roles on behavior.

The study was supposed to last for two weeks, but it had to be called off after only six days because the participants were beginning to suffer severe psychological effects.  This study is a classic in the field of social psychology, and the nature of evil and heroism.

v

Homosexuality

1973

Homosexuality removed from the DSM. The American Psychological Association does not consider homosexuality a mental disorder.

Type of Controversy

Homosexuality

Sociobiology

1975

This work, written by biologist Edward O. Wilson, serves as the precursor to the field of evolutionary psychology. Later, in 1976, Richard Dawkins publishes The Selfish Gene, which begins to popularize evolutionary psychology for looking at phenomena such as aggression and sexual behavior.

John Hinckley

1982

After John Hinkley Jr. shot President Ronald Reagan in an attempt to impress actress Jodi Foster, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity.  In response to the public outcry, the U.S. congress revised the law in 1984 so that the burden of proof for the insanity defense would rest on the defendant.

Howard Gardener

1983

Howard Gardener proposes his theory of multiple intelligences.  This theory contrasts the proposal that there is only one type of intelligence, as suggested by IQ tests.  This theory is controversial, and has not been fully researched.  Proposed intelligences include: Linguistic, Logical-Mathematic, Musical, Interpersonal, Intrapersonal, Naturalistic, Spatial, and Bodily-Kinesthetic.

Dr. Jack Kevorkian

1990

Dr. Jack Kevorkian is indicted for committing physician-assisted suicide.  The issue of “active euthanasia” is controversial in the U.S.

Columbine High School

1999

On April 20, 1999, Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris killed twelve students and one teacher at their high in Littleton, CO.  This event sparked discussion surrounding several controversies, including the nature/nurture debate, the question of free will, and the issues involved in playing violent video games.

Type of Controversy

Nature Nurture

Death with Dignity

2005

In 2005, the state of Oregon won their case allowing the state to continue the death with dignity act.  This act allows individuals with terminal illnesses (estimated death within six months) to petition the state in order to obtain a prescription for lethal drugs so that they may end their lives.  In 2008, the state of Washington implemented a similar measure.

Andrea Yates

2006

In 2001, Texas mother Andrea Yates drowned her five children in the family’s bathtub.   Yates was diagnosed with postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis.  Although she was initially convicted of capital murder, her case was successfully appealed, and in 2006 she was declared not guilty by reason of insanity.  Her case and those like it draw attention to the free will debate.

Type of Controversy

Free Will Debate